Not really total flops, but The Bumfholes had a bad run of luck. A year or so into my SWF save, Randy was going off to make a movie. I planned a big singles run for Zimmy while Randy was out, culminating with a Zimmy heel turn when Randy comes back, due to jealousy.
A week before Randy was to leave, Zimmy gut hurt, and would be out until a week after Randy came back. OK, so much for the singles run, but I could still do the heel turn based on jealousy. Except when Randy got back, his popularity and star quality went back to pre-movie levels.
Neither Bumfhole had anything that would really make them stand out as singles, they would just be lost in the upper-midcard shuffle. So they went back to being my top tag team and the whole storyline was scrapped.