So, I've gone through almost two years with only 3 story-lines I've really liked.
1: SWF Supremacy - I had signed John Greed, Brandon James, and Randy Bumfhole. Had them become a Stable with Greed being the Cult Leader, James being the big "dumb" guy who was easily manipulatable and an enforcer, and Bumfhole being a cocky young ladies man who just wants to make it big and this is his way how.
2: Ayso vs Shinzuku - Two guys from the indies, changed their names and completely repackaged them, built them up with a slow burn. Winning lowercard titles then having Shinzuku go to the main event first. Shinzuku got involved with SWF Supremacy, Ayso kayfabe left the company and returned (without anyone knowing) as "The Exiled" a masked mysterious wrestler and had Logan Wolfsbaine 'cause 3 people. Shinzuku went over John Greed and won his first world title at Vendetta II (CZCW's WM) then had Exiled turn back into Ayso and turn heel on Shinzuku.
3: I had Greg Gauge built up as a bonified Main Eventer and Matthew Keith became a Free Agent. I snagged him up so fast. My first thought was "Tag team" however, I made it a family blood rivalry with Keith not wanting to let his "less successful" brother ever get ahead of him.
Now those are the only 3 I'm truly proud of and I will remember in the future. However, the rest of the storylines consist of...
"I WANT DA TITLE. NO I WANT THE TITLE"
"I want to bring prestige to the title!"
"I'm main event status and you're not, you're going to have to get passed me if you want to be!"
I try to think of creative ideas but don't really strike gold with any of them. Is this me not using gimmicks to maybe help storylines along? Or maybe just not designing personalities in my head for workers?
I just need some general storyline / booking tips to not seem so bland