Punters' Kicking skills and vice versa

[Huckleberry]

Has this been discussed? Punters should be the next best kickers and vice versa, generally speaking. There is no relation from what I can tell.

[Sef0r]

[QUOTE=Huckleberry]Has this been discussed? Punters should be the next best kickers and vice versa, generally speaking. There is no relation from what I can tell.[/QUOTE] I would say the lack of replies could be your question....or whatever that is...hehehe :o I was totally confused so please rephrase :)

[Dirk9827]

I think what he means is.... Among non-field-goal kickers, the best candidate to kick field goals logically would be a punter. And conversely, among non-punters, the best candidate to punt the football logically would be a field goal kicker. Simply, the specialities both share a common theme of kicking a football. I believe he is contending that a punter should have a higher kicking rating that assigned in the game and a kicker should have a higher punting rating. The idea is that a punter or a kicker could do at least a serviceable job if pressed into action. As it stands now, the ratings are very, very low. Perhaps I am wrong, but I believe that is what he is trying to say.

[SkyDog]

[QUOTE=Dirk9827]The idea is that a punter or a kicker could do at least a serviceable job if pressed into action. As it stands now, the ratings are very, very low. Perhaps I am wrong, but I believe that is what he is trying to say.[/QUOTE]...and even if you are wrong about what his intention was, you are right in your assessment. :)

[Huckleberry]

Guys, the key to the interpretation is that Kicking is capitalized in the title. It was like a miniature puzzle. It was exceedingly clear to me, so I don't know what the problem could be. :)