I think Biggz hit the nail on the head right there. My expectations were incredible going into this show. I had Alberto del Rio vs. Edge, John Cena vs. The Miz, Triple H vs. Undertaker, and Daniel Bryan vs. Sheamus as all matches that I was REALLY looking forward to. I was also quite interested in Cody Rhodes vs. Rey Mysterio and Jerry Lawler vs. Michael Cole, and even looking forward to the six person tag match, hoping John Morrison and Dolph Ziggler would get a lot of action.
My expectations for in ring quality are not very high at all. I don't need a five star match to be thoroughly enjoyed.
In the end, I walked out happy with Alberto del Rio vs. Edge, Triple H vs. Undertaker, and Cody Rhodes vs. Rey Mysterio. All positives in my opinion, yet none even close to approached five star quality in my opinion.
However, I was not into John Cena vs. The Miz (I partly attribute this to being livid that Daniel Bryan / Sheamus would not be on the card. I had not checked the internet prior to and either the free show or PPV (can't remember which one) advertised the match being on, so I had no clue.) I thought the ending sucked.
Jerry Lawler and Michael Cole went way too long. Cole needed about two minutes of offence max, not eight minutes. This did not need to be a match at all.
And, while I enjoyed Snooki WAY more than I thought I would, Dolph and Morrison had no involvement aside from a couple moves whatsoever.
Really, the more I think about it, WrestleMania was pretty good, but the few blunders they did have were MAJOR to me.
Oh well, it was my first WrestleMania I have ever boughten / seen live, so that was pretty cool.