I haven't watches all that many anime shows, but you've done a good job with the reviews and I mostly agree with what you've said.
I saw Baccano when it was free on Hulu and I really enjoyed it. I suppose the shifting time thing was a little gimmicky, but I enjoyed it quite a bit and wouldn't mind watching it again.
I've watched some Cowboy Bebop back when it used to be on Adult Swim and enjoyed it, but I really should watch the series in order so the plot is more meaningful.
I have seen all of Death Note. I enjoyed it, but not quite as much as you did and I don't really have an urge to re-watch it like I have with the other two.
Are you going to be reviewing Full Metal Alchemist/Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood? I enjoyed both series (the latter more so) and would be interested in hearing your opinions if you've seen it.