As I said, I cannot fully remember now what happened in each round at this time. I know that I gave either round 1 or round 2 to Penn but I'm uncertain of which. I must say Biggz, you are persistant on the issue and I have to admire that. Anyway, hope this post clarified my position.
I would also like to say that I did not drink any kool-aid and was not influenced by anybody elses opinion. I also understand what you are saying about effective striking. You are indeed correct and I think Gabbo is taking a more literal definition of "effective". I remember that during the fight, Penn caught Edgar with some crisp punches (most of which were counter punches). But for every 1 clean punch that Penn landed, Edgar landed 3/4. So while I agree that Penn used his boxing ability well, it appeared that on that night Edgar used his better.